Instead of a point or star system, I use a word to describe the overall item. These ratings are:

Excellent, Great, Good
Decent, Eh, Limp
Lame, Bad, Garbage

02/20/06 Movies - Dragonheart, Masters of the Universe, Cyborg, Universal Soldier
04/08/06 Movies - Dragonheart: A New Beginning, Ninja Scroll, Street Fighter, Showdown in Little Tokyo, Red Scorpion
06/05/06 Games - Kirby Canvas Curse, Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney, Final Fantasy IV Advance, Yoshi's Story
09/07/06 Games - Super Mario 64 DS, Skullmonkeys, Sigma Star Saga, New Super Mario Bros., Vagrant Story
09/29/07 Games - Adventure, Mega Man 4, Drakengard, Dynowarz, Rockin' Kats, Puss 'n Boots
10/12/07 Games - River City Ransom, MDK2: Armageddon, Mega Man 5, Lufia, LEGO Star Wars, Ratchet and Clank 2
10/29/07 Games - Ducktales 2, Plok, Legend of Zelda, Ys Book 1 & 2, Pokemon Diamond, Rocket: Robot on Wheels
11/05/07 Games - Metroid, Kid Icarus, Ys 3, Ratchet and Clank 3, Splash Lake, Darkwing Duck
11/13/07 Games - ICO, Contra, Final Fantasy 7, Phoenix Wright 2, D, Monster Party
11/22/07 Games - Mega Man 6, Okami, Albert Odyssey, Psychosis, Neutopia, Contra: Hard Corps
12/02/07 Games - Kirby's Dream Land, Wind Waker, Bonk's Adventure, Scurge Hive, ChuChu Rocket, Gate of Thunder
12/13/07 Shows - Blackstar, Futurama, Family Guy, Robot Chicken
02/28/08 Games - Elemental Gimmick Gear, Alex Kidd Lost Stars, Killer7, Contra 3, Miracle Warriors, Shadowgate
04/02/08 Games - Gargoyle's Quest, Panzer Dragoon Saga, Neutopia 2, Rez, Phoenix Wright 3, Final Fantasy: Mystic Quest